Delivery to Bath, DeWitt, Eagle, Grand Ledge, Lansing, Portland, Potterville, and Wacousta on all orders over $10
New York Style Cookies so good they should be illegal.
Premium Ingredients for a luxury cookie experience —
At Criminal Cookie we strive to provide you with a luxury quality cookie. We take control of as many ingredients as possible by using only high-quality ingredients like Belgium Chocolate instead of bulk basic chocolate chips. We also make many ingredients in house. From our home roasted pumpkin blend, fresh ground spices, homemade toffee, caramel, and fudge.
Assault & Barry
Caramelized White Chocolate Raspberry
Usual Suspect
4 Chocolate Chunk with all Belgium White, Milk, Semisweet, and Dark Chocolates
Our story
We are a family owned and operated Michigan Cottage Law Bakery. My husband and I also happen to be fitness competitors/bodybuilders. With our sport and lifestyle, we indulged in sweets in moderation, and this led us to discover we were often disappointed when going out. Thats when we decided to educate ourselves and make our free meals at home. We studied recipes and techniques. We also paid special attention to the ingredients. We used only high-quality ingredients when making our food.
Fast forward to us coming up with this cookie recipe. We found our recipe would make 6 to 10 really big cookies. That was even too much for us, so we wanted to share with our friends and our families. We absolutely loved it when people would bite into our cookies and look surprised. Once we started getting request for our cookies, we found it hard to continue using the high-quality ingredients because we got so many requests and the ingredients got expensive. Thats when we found out people were willing to pay and not have us change the ingredients. One friend finally told us our cookies are so good they should be illegal “These are criminal”. Thats when Criminal Cookies llc was born.
Our ingredients
Our ingredients are what set us apart from other New York Style Cookie Bakeries. We try to use only high-quality ingredients when it comes to the ingredients we have to purchase. We also make several ingredients from scratch at our home bakery. This includes our locally grown pumpkin blend for the home roasted pumpkin puree we use in our pumpkin. We also grind fresh spices like nutmeg, all spice, cloves, cinnamon and others, when possible, to make sure the spice blends in our cookies are balanced for the dessert it is in. We make our own caramel, toffee, fudge, ganache, several other ingredients to make sure the cookies or other items are of the highest quality. Yes, this takes time, but we hope you taste the love we put into each of our products.
We deliver and you can catch us at a farm market or event near you.
Upcoming Schedule —
Check out our schedule so you can come see us.
3/9/2024
Lansing Bourbon Fest
3/23/24
Portland Art
Allergy Information: Here at Criminal Cookies and Candy we make all of our products from our home kitchen with care and love, but each treat may contain trace amounts of tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, and/or soy. Most of our products do contain eggs and dairy products of some sort but if they are not on the ingredient labels may contain trace amount of dairy and eggs as well.